Patreon Can’t Solve Its Porn Pirate Problem

Patreon Can’t Solve Its Porn Pirate Problem

Last fall, a prolific photographer who asked not to be named noticed a sharp, unexplained drop-off in earnings on his Patreon page, where fans shell out cash for tiered subscriptions to his photos of well-lit nude models. Then, in December, he received an anonymous email with a link to a website called Yiff.Party. When he clicked, he blanched: Thousands of his photos were laid out on the open web for free.

For five years, the libidinous pirates of Yiff.Party have siphoned masses of paywalled Patreon porn off of the platform and shared it for free. Two years ago, Patreon was determined to shut them down. Instead, the platform has effectively given up, despite desperate protests from affected creators.

Yiff.Party doesn’t look like much: a basic, blocky, white and lavender website with a changelog documenting the latest free art dumps and their respective creators. There might be eight new posts an hour, as well as calls for patrons to help fill out incomplete collections. A lot of it is furry porn—“yiff” is a term in the furry community referencing sexual activity—but Yiff.Party hosts anything that falls under the category of “lewds.” That includes smutty cosplays, vanilla softcore, hentai comics, 3D sci-fi sex stills, plus whatever Patreon-hosted art pirates dump there. (Patreon’s guidelines on adult content prohibit “real people engaging in sexual acts such as masturbation or sexual intercourse on camera.”)

“I am an artist, I live off my work, and sometimes Patreon is the only income I have,” the photographer whose work had been stolen tells WIRED. In bold, capital-lettered text on his Patreon page, he warned “WHOEVER IS DOING THIS” to “PLEASE STOP FUCKING ME OVER.” In the meantime, he can only hope that whichever fox has been gifting him cash with one hand and pirating his works with the other grows a conscience. Because one thing’s for sure: Patreon isn’t helping him, despite a 2018 pledge in Kotaku that it would fight Yiff.Party “vigorously” and “on behalf of our creators.”

This month, the owner of Yiff.Party, who goes by Dozes, sent WIRED a screenshot that he says contains the only two messages in his inbox from the domain @patreon.com: one “Notice of Infringing Material” on July 18, 2018, and a polite follow-up on September 26, 2018. “Patreon has definitely been aware of yiff.party since 2015, but that's the only instance of them directly contacting me,” Dozes says.

Dozes says Yiff.Party receives about unique 95,000 visitors daily and that it’s only growing. He started it, he says, “to archive content,” in part, for fans whose favorite artwork disappears once a creator leaves Patreon or gets banned. In a 2018 interview, Dozes provided a different rationale—“simply to make paid Patreon content available for free”—but said both then and now that he’s not out to get creators or cost them income. Despite this, those whose work has ended up on the site have described reactions ranging from existential sadness to financial anxiety.

Patrons scrape huge amounts of premium Patreon posts and import them onto Yiff.Party, where they are accessible to anyone with at least one click. Dozes says that the site currently stores over 20 terabytes of data and accepts donations that go toward server upkeep.

Despite its gung-ho statement to Kotaku two years ago, Patreon now says its terms of service effectively tie its hands. “We can’t do anything,” says Colin Sullivan, Patreon’s head of legal. “We don’t enforce [copyright] because we don’t have a license to the content.”

Sullivan didn’t hear back from Yiff.Party after those two cease and desist notices; he still hasn’t. Patreon says it also appealed to the company that hosts Yiff.Party, which, according to Sullivan, was based in France. “International hosting companies often turn a blind eye to a lot of things,” he adds.

Advertisement

In May 2019, months after it reached out to Dozes, Patreon posted a blog describing its stance on piracy. “Protecting the works of our creators across the entirety of the internet is not something our policies or enforcement efforts are equipped to handle,” wrote Patreon copyright lawyer Weston Dombroski. He further compares Patreon to a landlord, “limited in both responsibility and the remedies they can seek when theft occurs in your apartment.” Patreon’s “trust and safety” guidelines “give creators as much control of their businesses as possible,” which includes 100 percent ownership of their work.

In other words, it’s legally on Patreon’s creators to enforce copyright on their own work. As Sullivan notes, it’s a good thing that their creators maintain that copyright and not the platform. And yet, with a new post dump every seven minutes or so, Yiff.Party is an increasing menace to Patreon porn society. At least some rental contracts give tenants the power to impel their landlord to install window guards against theft.

Individual attempts at action have also proven fruitless. In what looks like a nod toward generosity, Yiff.Party offers a “Contact” button on the bottom right of its page. Creators have sent DMCA takedown notices to the linked email address—sometimes several—and received no response. As a next step they might try to find Yiff.Party’s host and registrar information to lodge a complaint, which is where things get even more confusing.

Yiff.Party’s backend is a bit of a chimera by design. Dozes employs a bit of tech called a “reverse proxy.” A typical proxy obfuscates the identity of the user accessing a server; a reverse proxy hides the identity of the server the client accesses. Between Yiff.Party’s server and the yiff.party website sits another server. “Yiff.party's main server stays hidden because the ‘real’ IP address isn't being exposed since traffic is routed through a proxy,” says Dozes. Reverse proxies aren’t uncommon; large sites might use one to help them run faster.

“It’s essentially a VPN, but for a website,” Dozes adds. “If our real hosting provider found out they hosted the site, we would be at risk of losing all our data.”

Going through Patreon has not helped much either. One model and content creator who asked to remain anonymous has twice emailed the platform about removing her content from Yiff.Party. One time was in reference to a DMCA takedown request; in the other, she reveals the identity of a suspected pirate patron. In screenshots from January 2020 shared with WIRED, a Patreon support representative told the model that the company “has been made aware of this website and has been taking action against it.” The representative declined to provide a timeline for resolution, and did not share the results of the investigation into the suspicious patron. Her content continues to show up on Yiff.Party.

Platforms large and small have for years relegated responsibility for bad things that happen to their users onto those same users and their personal networks. In the case of Yiff.Party, Patreon appears to be following that same playbook. “For creators, we encourage them to focus on connecting more with their fans and focusing on their patrons who care about them, and not the ones who are going to upload [their work] somewhere else,” Sullivan says.

Creators could use software watermarks or other techniques to root out the culprit. But even that doesn’t provide a solid indicator of who did what. In 2003, the Recording Industry Association of America filed 261 lawsuits against pirates for allegedly sharing songs over P2P networks—with some misfires. IP addresses weren’t immensely helpful in identifying pirates, and sometimes led to false allegations. Patreon says it collects some information that could point to who’s pirating, but that it’s difficult to nail down the culprit or prove their intent.

Advertisement

The head of piracy-focused publication Torrentfreak, who goes by Ernesto Van Der Sar, doesn’t consider what’s going on at Yiff.Party a security issue. He also agrees that it’s nearly impossible to prevent patrons from leaking content, despite identifying software stickers. “You can compare it to Netflix perhaps,” he says. “People with an account there can download and share the content with specialized tools. This is content from major companies that's worth billions of dollars and protected by high-grade DRM. If that's still possible, it will be hard for Patreon to prevent it from happening.”

Last May, a person who went by Jane posted on Yiff.Party’s forum to say they’re the mother of one of the models posted on the site and owns the photos as well. “What is the process of removing these,” she asked. Ever since, Yiff.Party regulars have dutifully shitposted in the thread, some wondering whether it’s a troll post, and others earnestly explaining the ideology behind their piracy.

“There’s really nothing you can do once you post some good stuff online,” said one. Said another, “Nothing you can do. It's a catch22 scenario: if you don't remove it people continue to pirate but if you do take it down the piracy just increases.”

Said a third, “Hi Jane. Welcome to the Internet.” They continued, echoing the first commenter’s sentiments. “Even if you delete it from a website someone somewhere still has a copy of it. This is especially true if it’s hilarious, embarrassing or pornographic in nature. The bigger the deal you make out of it the worst [sic] it gets for you and anyone else involved.”


Read more: https://www.wired.com/story/patreon-porn-piracy-yiffparty/

52 thoughts on “Patreon Can’t Solve Its Porn Pirate Problem

  1. Здесь вы можете заказать копию любого сайта под ключ, недорого и качественно, при этом не тратя свое время на различные программы и фриланс-сервисы.

    Клонированию подлежат сайты как на конструкторах, так и на движках:
    – Tilda (Тильда)
    – Wix (Викс)
    – Joomla (Джумла)
    – WordPress (Вордпресс)
    – Bitrix (Битрикс)
    и т.д.
    телефон 8-996-725-20-75 звоните пишите viber watsapp
    Копируются не только одностраничные сайты на подобии Landing Page, но и многостраничные. Создается полная копия сайта и настраиваются формы для отправки заявок и сообщений. Кроме того, подключается админка (админ панель), позволяющая редактировать код сайта, изменять текст, загружать изображения и документы.

    Здесь вы получите весь комплекс услуг по копированию, разработке и продвижению сайта в Яндексе и Google.

    Хотите узнать сколько стоит сделать копию сайта?
    напишите нам
    8-996-725-20-75 звоните пишите viber watsapp

    Here you can order a copy of any site turnkey, inexpensive and high quality, while not wasting your time on various programs and freelance services.

    Cloning sites are subject to both designers and engines:
    – Tilda (Tilda)
    – Wix (Wicks)
    – Joomla (Joomla)
    – WordPress (WordPress)
    – Bitrix (Bitrix)
    etc.
    phone 8-996-725-20-75 call write viber watsapp
    Not only single-page sites like Landing Page are copied, but also multi-page sites. A full copy of the site is created and forms for sending requests and messages are set up. In addition, the admin panel is connected, which allows you to edit the site code, change the text, upload images and documents.

    Here you will get a full range of services for copying, development and promotion of the site in Yandex and Google.

    Do you want to know how much it costs to make a copy of the site?
    write to us
    8-996-725-20-75 call write viber watsapp

  2. Aber welche Formen von Haarausfall gibt es noch? Und welche Mittel helfen am besten? Lesen Sie jetzt alles darüber! So wird etwa eine hormonell-erblich bedingte Alopezie anders behandelt als ein Kreisrunder Haarausfall oder ein Haarausfall aufgrund von Mangelernährung.

  3. Generic are the identical clones of branded medications. The only difference in the two being the patent and the price at which it is sold. It contains the same active ingredients and match the branded drug in terms of both pharmacokinetic and chloroquine pharmacodynamic properties. Be it dosage, strength, route of administration, safety, efficiancy, or use, genetics match their counterparts in all aspects.

  4. generic viagra review [url=http://genviagrafx.com/#]generic viagra canada[/url] buy viagra 20mg online overnight delivery
    viagra 25mg online – viagra online fast delivery france viagra reviews side effects community

  5. levitra pills forum rules cheapest levitra online cheap
    levitra in thailand levitra 20mg – howmuch the officia price
    of levitra in usa canadian pharmacy levitra professional
    delete all board cookies

  6. I wanted to send a small message so as to say thanks to you for all of the amazing ways you are sharing on this site. My considerable internet look up has now been recognized with professional facts and techniques to go over with my relatives. I ‘d state that that many of us website visitors are extremely lucky to be in a perfect place with many perfect people with great opinions. I feel pretty grateful to have seen your entire webpages and look forward to really more awesome times reading here. Thanks a lot once more for everything.

  7. I am writing to let you understand of the impressive discovery my wife’s girl undergone reading through your web site. She came to understand so many things, which include how it is like to possess a great teaching character to have other individuals quite simply fully grasp a variety of multifaceted subject matter. You actually exceeded people’s desires. I appreciate you for distributing these useful, trustworthy, explanatory and cool guidance on that topic to Ethel.

  8. Приветствую Вас дамы и господа! Предлагаем Вашему вниманию интересный сайт для заказа бурения скважин на воду. Заказывайте скважину для воды в ЕВРОБУРСЕРВИС – получите доступ к экологически чистой природной воде по самым выгодным в Минске ценам! Более подробная информация размещена тут https://drive.google.com/file/d/14WNRakU9DtUUJSwzsL4smlzgF0mODipG/view?usp=sharing
    От всей души Вам всех благ!

  9. Приветствую Вас друзья! Есть такой интересный сайт для заказа бурения скважин на воду. Заказывайте скважину для воды в ЕВРОБУРСЕРВИС – получите доступ к экологически чистой природной воде по самым выгодным в Минске ценам! Более подробная информация размещена тут https://drive.google.com/file/d/14WNRakU9DtUUJSwzsL4smlzgF0mODipG/view?usp=sharing
    Увидимся!

  10. Приветствую Вас друзья! Предлагаем Вашему вниманию интересный сайт для заказа бурения скважин на воду. Заказывайте скважину для воды в ЕВРОБУРСЕРВИС – получите доступ к экологически чистой природной воде по самым выгодным в Минске ценам! Более подробная информация размещена тут https://drive.google.com/file/d/14WNRakU9DtUUJSwzsL4smlzgF0mODipG/view?usp=sharing
    От всей души Вам всех благ!

  11. Здравствуйте друзья! Есть такой замечательный сайт для заказа бурения скважин на воду. Заказывайте скважину для воды в ЕВРОБУРСЕРВИС – получите доступ к экологически чистой природной воде по самым выгодным в Минске ценам! Более подробная информация размещена тут https://drive.google.com/file/d/14WNRakU9DtUUJSwzsL4smlzgF0mODipG/view?usp=sharing
    Увидимся!

  12. buy cialis no prescription
    cialis 20mg side effects all times are utc
    tadalafil 5mg
    – generic cialis uk suppliers
    cialis for daily use 5mg ascending order

  13. I precisely wished to thank you so much once more. I do not know what I might have implemented in the absence of these tactics shown by you regarding that concern. It previously was an absolute difficult scenario in my view, however , observing a skilled fashion you handled the issue took me to cry with happiness. I will be happier for this assistance and in addition pray you find out what a great job you have been getting into training the rest thru a blog. Most probably you haven’t encountered all of us.

  14. I am also writing to make you know of the cool experience my cousin’s daughter went through visiting your site. She discovered lots of details, including what it is like to have an incredible teaching mood to make folks easily fully understand certain complicated subject areas. You truly surpassed her desires. Thanks for displaying such interesting, dependable, informative and easy tips on this topic to Emily.

  15. My husband and i got now delighted Peter managed to do his survey through the ideas he got through your web site. It’s not at all simplistic to simply find yourself handing out secrets which some other people may have been trying to sell. We grasp we have you to give thanks to because of that. The most important illustrations you have made, the easy website menu, the relationships you can make it easier to foster – it’s got mostly astounding, and it’s letting our son in addition to our family feel that the article is thrilling, which is extraordinarily indispensable. Many thanks for the whole thing!

  16. Спешу сообщить читающим отзывы на данном сайте и в сети интернет в общем, Анонимные отзывы мягко говоря “попахивают” происками конкурентов, т.к. написаны они под копирку без конкретных фактов и несут в себе цель просто “очернить”, “затроллить” и проч. Но, мы будем это использовать как положительный инфоповод для читающих эти “подставные” отзывы.
    Отвечаем на самые интересные тезисы:
    1.Наша компания существует и по сей день аж с 2009 года. И что подразумевает под собою юридически утверждение “фактически нет” для нас осталось загадкой!
    2.Она имеет юридический адрес, который как и у многих компаний может меняться без уведомления посетителей сайта и кого либо еще, кроме соответствующих органов. Так же спешу сообщить, что адреса юридические и фактические по закону могут не совпадать.
    3.Номер телефона сейчас можно указать любой привязав префиксы 8(499) и 8(495) к мобильному оператору, но не видим в этом смысла,т.к. мобильный указанный на сайте принадлежит руководителю компании,или вам по старинке нравиться ждать пока вас переведут на человека который принимает решения в компании и примет решение о цене и сроках вашего запроса?!
    4.Е-майл указан так же по желанию руководителя, Корпорация Mail.ru Group является на 100% безопасным партнером по всем необходимым параметрам связанным с почтовыми серверами.
    5.Есть штатные сотрудники, без которых деятельность компании не возможна, бухгалтер ,ген.директор, дизайнер, программист, так же как и все компании без исключения по необходимости привлекаются сотрудники на проекты по срочным контрактам как исполнители, это общепринятая мировая практика сокращения издержек любого предприятия, не видим в этом ничего зазорного, а наоборот гордимся такой возможностью!
    6.Платформа wix зарекомендовала себя как надежный партнер со всеми удобствами по созданию и обслуживанию веб-ресурсов любой сложности. Многие клиенты сократили издержки на обслуживание сайта после его создания. Выбор на чем делать собственный сайт принадлежит самим выбирающим , на wix мы и сделали свой выбор и не пожалели ни разу! Или вам нравятся HTML странички,созданные на коленке и требующие ресурсы даже для изменения телефона или картинки ))) Мы пас!
    Надеемся, что наши ответы пролили свет на наши “темные”)) дела в сети интернет по обслуживанию клиентов! Будем рады ответить на все интересующие вопросы по телефону,емайлу или форме обратной связи на сайте компании! Всех благ и не болейте!
    Перейти specialbrand

  17. Not giving away your quick-wittedness is quite a unyielding task. Viewing stories, videos, and likes is not the undamaged @arewaa_hottest_pics index of footprints that we pull out on Instagram. There is not unexceptionally a die for to be discovered. Examine competitors, new photos of the former or previous, so that without hearsay – it is possible. How not to leak yourself? We pass on analyze all workable situations, how and what not to “light up”.
    This was not ever the suitcase – just a few years ago, few factors could transmit away that a themselves has in these times entered Instagram. Fortunately, you can restful remain disguised using Insta.
    If you have such a task to remain anonymously and unnoticeably in a social network, then inspect the following methods. If you just scroll the feed-do not put likes, at all. The retailing of your actions purposefulness be stored instead of a crave prematurely by way of people who subscribe to you.
    Dregs to observe – this is joke of the most palpable actions. After all, they are many times less than “hearts”, respectively, so it attracts even more attention.
    Analyse not to shield storis at all. Innumerable users, after the broadsheet of its history followed the statistics, yet, who most oftentimes comes to them. If there are decided people after whom you hunger for to be left unidentified – supervise stories as carefully as possible.

  18. I have to express my admiration for your kind-heartedness supporting those who really need guidance on this one question. Your personal commitment to getting the message up and down appears to be quite practical and has without exception empowered guys like me to realize their objectives. The important guideline indicates a lot a person like me and much more to my fellow workers. Thanks a ton; from each one of us.

  19. I wanted to send a small comment to be able to appreciate you for all of the marvelous facts you are showing on this website. My prolonged internet research has at the end of the day been rewarded with incredibly good strategies to write about with my relatives. I would admit that many of us readers actually are very much fortunate to live in a fabulous place with many awesome people with very helpful secrets. I feel truly blessed to have encountered your weblog and look forward to tons of more exciting moments reading here. Thank you again for a lot of things.

  20. I must express thanks to this writer for bailing me out of this type of scenario. After searching throughout the the web and finding ideas which are not beneficial, I believed my entire life was over. Living without the presence of solutions to the problems you’ve sorted out through the site is a critical case, and those which may have adversely damaged my career if I had not come across your site. That knowledge and kindness in dealing with all the stuff was very useful. I am not sure what I would’ve done if I hadn’t encountered such a solution like this. It’s possible to at this moment look ahead to my future. Thanks for your time very much for this specialized and sensible help. I won’t hesitate to refer your web site to anyone who needs and wants tips about this topic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.